universo-virtual.com

buytrendz.net

thisforall.net

benchpressgains.com

qthzb.com

mindhunter9.com

dwjqp1.com

secure-signup.net

ahaayy.com

soxtry.com

tressesindia.com

puresybian.com

krpano-chs.com

cre8workshop.com

hdkino.org

peixun021.com

qz786.com

utahperformingartscenter.org

maw-pr.com

zaaksen.com

ypxsptbfd7.com

worldqrmconference.com

shangyuwh.com

eejssdfsdfdfjsd.com

playminecraftfreeonline.com

trekvietnamtour.com

your-business-articles.com

essaywritingservice10.com

hindusamaaj.com

joggingvideo.com

wandercoups.com

onlinenewsofindia.com

worldgraphic-team.com

bnsrz.com

wormblaster.net

tongchengchuyange0004.com

internetknowing.com

breachurch.com

peachesnginburlesque.com

dataarchitectoo.com

clientfunnelformula.com

30pps.com

cherylroll.com

ks2252.com

webmanicura.com

osostore.com

softsmob.com

sofietsshotel.com

facetorch.com

nylawyerreview.com

apapromotions.com

shareparelli.com

goeaglepointe.com

thegreenmanpubphuket.com

karotorossian.com

publicsensor.com

taiwandefence.com

epcsur.com

odskc.com

inzziln.info

leaiiln.info

cq-oa.com

dqtianshun.com

southstills.com

tvtv98.com

thewellington-hotel.com

bccaipiao.com

colectoresindustrialesgs.com

shenanddcg.com

capriartfilmfestival.com

replicabreitlingsale.com

thaiamarinnewtoncorner.com

gkmcww.com

mbnkbj.com

andrewbrennandesign.com

cod54.com

luobinzhang.com

bartoysdirect.com

taquerialoscompadresdc.com

aaoodln.info

amcckln.info

drvrnln.info

dwabmln.info

fcsjoln.info

hlonxln.info

kcmeiln.info

kplrrln.info

fatcatoons.com

91guoys.com

signupforfreehosting.com

faithfirst.net

zjyc28.com

tongchengjinyeyouyue0004.com

nhuan6.com

oldgardensflowers.com

lightupthefloor.com

bahamamamas-stjohns.com

ly2818.com

905onthebay.com

fonemenu.com

notanothermovie.com

ukrainehighclassescort.com

meincmagazine.com

av-5858.com

yallerdawg.com

donkeythemovie.com

corporatehospitalitygroup.com

boboyy88.com

miteinander-lernen.com

dannayconsulting.com

officialtomsshoesoutletstore.com

forsale-amoxil-amoxicillin.net

generictadalafil-canada.net

guitarlessonseastlondon.com

lesliesrestaurants.com

mattyno9.com

nri-homeloans.com

rtgvisas-qatar.com

salbutamolventolinonline.net

sportsinjuries.info

topsedu.xyz

xmxm7.com

x332.xyz

sportstrainingblog.com

autopartspares.com

readguy.net

soniasegreto.com

bobbygdavis.com

wedsna.com

rgkntk.com

bkkmarketplace.com

zxqcwx.com

breakupprogram.com

boxcardc.com

unblockyoutubeindonesia.com

fabulousbookmark.com

beat-the.com

guatemala-sailfishing-vacations-charters.com

magie-marketing.com

kingstonliteracy.com

guitaraffinity.com

eurelookinggoodapparel.com

howtolosecheekfat.net

marioncma.org

oliviadavismusic.com

shantelcampbellrealestate.com

shopleborn13.com

topindiafree.com

v-visitors.net

qazwsxedcokmijn.com

parabis.net

terriesandelin.com

luxuryhomme.com

studyexpanse.com

ronoom.com

djjky.com

053hh.com

originbluei.com

baucishotel.com

33kkn.com

intrinsiqresearch.com

mariaescort-kiev.com

mymaguk.com

sponsored4u.com

crimsonclass.com

bataillenavale.com

searchtile.com

ze-stribrnych-struh.com

zenithalhype.com

modalpkv.com

bouisset-lafforgue.com

useupload.com

37r.net

autoankauf-muenster.com

bantinbongda.net

bilgius.com

brabustermagazine.com

indigrow.org

miicrosofts.net

mysmiletravel.com

selinasims.com

spellcubesapp.com

usa-faction.com

snn01.com

hope-kelley.com

bancodeprofissionais.com

zjccp99.com

liturgycreator.com

weedsmj.com

majorelenco.com

colcollect.com

androidnews-jp.com

hypoallergenicdogsnames.com

dailyupdatez.com

foodphotographyreviews.com

cricutcom-setup.com

chprowebdesign.com

katyrealty-kanepa.com

tasramar.com

bilgipinari.org

four-am.com

indiarepublicday.com

inquick-enbooks.com

iracmpi.com

kakaschoenen.com

lsm99flash.com

nana1255.com

ngen-niagara.com

technwzs.com

virtualonlinecasino1345.com

wallpapertop.net

nova-click.com

abeautifulcrazylife.com

diggmobile.com

denochemexicana.com

eventhalfkg.com

medcon-taiwan.com

life-himawari.com

myriamshomes.com

nightmarevue.com

allstarsru.com

bestofthebuckeyestate.com

bestofthefirststate.com

bestwireless7.com

declarationintermittent.com

findhereall.com

jingyou888.com

lsm99deal.com

lsm99galaxy.com

moozatech.com

nuagh.com

patliyo.com

philomenamagikz.net

rckouba.net

saturnunipessoallda.com

tallahasseefrolics.com

thematurehardcore.net

totalenvironment-inthatquietearth.com

velislavakaymakanova.com

vermontenergetic.com

sizam-design.com

kakakpintar.com

begorgeouslady.com

1800birks4u.com

2wheelstogo.com

6strip4you.com

bigdata-world.net

emailandco.net

gacapal.com

jharpost.com

krishnaastro.com

lsm99credit.com

mascalzonicampani.com

sitemapxml.org

thecityslums.net

topagh.com

flairnetwebdesign.com

bangkaeair.com

beneventocoupon.com

noternet.org

oqtive.com

smilebrightrx.com

decollage-etiquette.com

1millionbestdownloads.com

7658.info

bidbass.com

devlopworldtech.com

digitalmarketingrajkot.com

fluginfo.net

naqlafshk.com

passion-decouverte.com

playsirius.com

spacceleratorintl.com

stikyballs.com

top10way.com

yokidsyogurt.com

zszyhl.com

16firthcrescent.com

abogadolaboralistamd.com

apk2wap.com

aromacremeria.com

banparacard.com

bosmanraws.com

businessproviderblog.com

caltonosa.com

calvaryrevivalchurch.org

chastenedsoulwithabrokenheart.com

cheminotsgardcevennes.com

cooksspot.com

cqxzpt.com

deesywig.com

deltacartoonmaps.com

despixelsetdeshommes.com

duocoracaobrasileiro.com

fareshopbd.com

goodpainspills.com

kobisitecdn.com

makaigoods.com

mgs1454.com

piccadillyresidences.com

radiolaondafresca.com

rubendorf.com

searchengineimprov.com

sellmyhrvahome.com

shugahouseessentials.com

sonihullquad.com

subtractkilos.com

valeriekelmansky.com

vipasdigitalmarketing.com

voolivrerj.com

zeelonggroup.com

1015southrockhill.com

10x10b.com

111-online-casinos.com

191cb.com

3665arpentunitd.com

aitesonics.com

bag-shokunin.com

brightotech.com

communication-digitale-services.com

covoakland.org

dariaprimapack.com

freefortniteaccountss.com

gatebizglobal.com

global1entertainmentnews.com

greatytene.com

hiroshiwakita.com

iktodaypk.com

jahatsakong.com

meadowbrookgolfgroup.com

newsbharati.net

platinumstudiosdesign.com

slotxogamesplay.com

strikestaruk.com

trucosdefortnite.com

ufabetrune.com

weddedtowhitmore.com

12940brycecanyonunitb.com

1311dietrichoaks.com

2monarchtraceunit303.com

601legendhill.com

850elaine.com

adieusolasomade.com

andora-ke.com

bestslotxogames.com

cannagomcallen.com

endlesslyhot.com

iestpjva.com

ouqprint.com

pwmaplefest.com

qtylmr.com

rb88betting.com

buscadogues.com

1007macfm.com

born-wild.com

growthinvests.com

promocode-casino.com

proyectogalgoargentina.com

wbthompson-art.com

whitemountainwheels.com

7thavehvl.com

developmethis.com

funkydogbowties.com

travelodgegrandjunction.com

gao-town.com

globalmarketsuite.com

blogshippo.com

hdbka.com

proboards67.com

outletonline-michaelkors.com

kalkis-research.com

thuthuatit.net

buckcash.com

hollistercanada.com

docterror.com

asadart.com

vmayke.org

erwincomputers.com

dirimart.org

okkii.com

loteriasdecehegin.com

mountanalog.com

healingtaobritain.com

ttxmonitor.com

bamthemes.com

nwordpress.com

11bolabonanza.com

avgo.top

How one Google featured snippet is killing commercial list-based content - SEO
Tuesday, July 1, 2025
spot_img

Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

How one Google featured snippet is killing commercial list-based content

Recent Google scandals have raised concerns about search result fairness, accuracy, transparency and the ethics of big brands’ dominance.

This article explores how these factors collide by examining Google’s use of search engine results page (SERP) list-based features to further their monetary gains while going against their own content guidelines and advice.

By the end, you will see how list-based SERP features directly copy programmatic SEO practices, which Google’s own spokespeople have long labeled as spam.

These features not only fail in their promise to enhance the user experience but also diminish the visibility of legitimate publishers with original ideas, worsening the search landscape.

How From sources across the web came to dominate search results

Google started experimenting with carousels to 2017 and later, around 2020, introducing content summaries for list-based content

Around 2022, Google started introducing a SERP feature, From sources across the web, which today appears to have replaced all previous list-based content summary SERP features.

Table 1. A timeline of Google’s attempts to summarize and organize list-based content from web publishers
Table 1. A timeline of Google’s attempts to summarize and organize list-based content from web publishers

Google now uses From sources across the web for a variety of search queries, mainly with commercial intent, such as: 

  • Best (e.g., best date spots in {city}, best small towns near {city}, best {service provider}, best {software type}, best {software type for})
  • Checklist (e.g., YouTube checklist)
  • {type} software (e.g., SEO software, analytics software, ERP software)
  • Date ideas in {location} (e.g., date ideas for couples in Dallas, date ideas for families in California)
  • {industry} tools (e.g., SEO tools, SaaS tools, Analytics tools)

How the From sources across the web relates to programmatic SEO 

When people think about programmatic content, often they think of content generated programmatically (via ChatGPT or equivalent) or spam (as Google spokespeople have referred to). 

Programmatic SEO is actually database-driven. All information is organized in a database, which then populates dynamically a page template to create unique pages. 

The content aspect of programmatic SEO (i.e., populating the database) can be generated programmatically (i.e., via generative AI), but that has not historically been the case. 

Typically, it’s pulled from the internal databases of big enterprises. For example, think about these databases and how they are used: 

  • The hotel list of booking.com is used to create content in formats like {hotel type/descriptor – e.g., luxury, family} hotels in {location}
  • The flights database of Expedia is used to create content in formats like cheap flights to {destination}
  • The company database of G2 is used to create content in formats like best {industry} software

To populate the data in this SERP feature, Google is pulling data from the most prolific list-based content websites, which in many industries are also big enterprises and combining it with its own data on entities and brands. 

This is described in some of their patent filings, specifically patent US11720920B1 from 2021, which describes a content management system or storage system (otherwise – a database) where eligible content items (entities, brands) are combined with top search results to create a combined search result item. 

how the SERP feature works - patent imagehow the SERP feature works - patent image

This practice directly aligns with the description of programmatic SEO or otherwise – database-driven content structured via a reusable template before being presented to the user. 

Let’s explore the use of this in detail.

Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


See terms.


How this practice is worse for both users and publishers and why Google is doing it nonetheless (Spoiler alert: it’s money)

Now that we’ve covered the basics and how we got here, let’s explore the age-old question: 

Does this actually improve search results and the user experience, or is it yet another tactic that Google uses for its gain?

Breakdown of SERPs accuracy, authoritativeness and overall quality in relation to search intent

Let’s dive into a searcher’s journey. Consider the query [best SEO consultants], where we encounter the From sources across the web SERP feature.

We want to assess the information’s validity and its relevance to the query. From the image below, we can draw the following insights.

Best SEO consultants SERPsBest SEO consultants SERPs

There are 24 slots for SEO consultants to be added:

  • Only 14 of those slots are filled in by actual SEO consultants and 10 of the entities mentioned are organizations or agencies.
  • 7 of 14 people mentioned in the SERP feature no longer have an SEO consulting practice, meaning – they have either now moved on to other companies (including being hired by Google), founded their own companies or are no longer taking SEO clients
  • Only 2 out of the 14 people mentioned in the SERP feature are women and only 3 are people of color. 
  • Out of the 24 slots in this SERP feature, only 7 of the slots are filled with data that directly and accurately addresses the user query.

(We now have yet another hurdle to surpass to get a leveled playing field as women or minorities.)

Let’s take it a step further and answer the question – where is Google pulling this information from? It’s Google, so they must be using some quality sources and a good variety of them, right?

Well, no. 

Upon inspecting the sources further, we can note several major flaws with the selection of sources that inform this SERP feature: 

  • Google chooses sources that clearly do not match the search intent, e.g., SEO expert ≠ SEO consultant
Web sourcesWeb sources
  • Google sources information from non-authoritative, non-factual, affiliate/sponsored link sites or spammy websites.
    • For context, out of 80 links featured as part of the “best seo consultants” search results, there are:
      • 30 from LinkedIn Pulse (primarily AI-generated content).
      • 7 from icreativez.com.
      • 4 from Medium blogs.
      • There are very few links in the sample (see below) that would be considered good and definitive sources to use for such a query.
      • There are only 27 unique sources that informed this SERP feature.
Link domain analysisLink domain analysis
  • Google does not feature any original research to create these panels. 
  • Google does not fact-check the information featured.
  • Google does not use all of the web sources available to it to create these summaries. 

What are Google’s motivations for doing this?

I imagine what many of you are thinking, “Well, if they actually analyze all web sources to create these panels – imagine the costs involved in delivering this information at scale, with precision.”

Yes, that’s true. Aside from being costly and resource-intensive for Google to do correctly, it will also involve not relying on links or click data but actually understanding the content of webpages. But as Google has hinted in their antitrust trial, they likely don’t know how to do this yet. 

Dig deeper. 7 must-see Google Search ranking documents in antitrust trial exhibits

Still, we have to understand why they are doing this in the first place. What type of websites usually invest in and benefit the most from programmatic SEO (database-driven) content?

The first thing that comes to mind is big enterprises with huge databases because that’s what you need to run a successful programmatic SEO campaign. Think: 

  • Expedia, TripAdvisor, Skyscanner, Booking.com in travel. 
  • Zapier, Canva in SaaS. 
  • G2 and Clutch in reviews.

Representatives from Expedia and Booking.com testified against Google in the antitrust trial. They accuse the organization of monopolizing search results by unfairly promoting their competitor micro-organizations (like Google Flights and Google Hotels) and introducing changes to search results pages while simultaneously raising advertising prices to push competition away.

Going back to the From sources across the web snippet, the only way to surpass this block of text is to pay for a sponsored placement. 

“From sources across the web” with ads“From sources across the web” with ads

List-based queries are entirely a pay-to-play game now. Pay a third party to feature you in spammy lists or pay Google to appear before the SERP feature as a sponsored post. 

That’s just another way for Google to directly target companies that would otherwise dominate the search results organically for these types of queries, making sure that either the companies pay them for visibility or they lose on user clicks to their website. Yet again, that’s nothing new. 

While there is no research looking at click interactions with this particular featured snippet, data from 2017 showed that featured snippets appear at the top position in about a third of results.

There is also a rise in the number of clicks they receive on average – 2017 data showed featured snippets receive around 8.6% of clicks when in Position 1 on average, while a more recent study from 2022 revealed that this number has risen to 35.1%, meaning on average featured snippets received 35.1% of the total click share. 

Since these two studies were published, featured snippets appear to have become even more prevalent – in terms of screen size and how often they surfaced. I imagine a present-day study on featured snippets would be much gloomier for clicks on organic results.

This practice hurts not only users and publishers but also the search and information landscape

Beyond all of these issues, this practice enforces a very big problem – it demotes truly unique and original ideas, worsening the search and information landscape. 

In many cases I looked through as part of my research, the user is worse off with the information listed in the SERP feature than if they were to visit any of the top-ranked pages.

Let me explain. 

Suppose you have or work for an independent website and your niche’s search results are dominated by these snippets when you start creating your content in a listicle format. 

In that case, you will need to look at the top-ranked results and the search snippet data and, to a degree, replicate the data in them as part of the list you create. 

But, the key thing that any reputable consultant will say is to improve the list by adding new ideas, concepts, original data, research, new perspectives, etc.

So, you include a bunch of original, highly relevant ideas in your lists. Ideas that no other website has written about. Would they be featured in the snippet? No. 

Not unless other sites mention them, too, at which point they will no longer be original. Your small website is unlikely to be featured anyway due to a lack of perceived authoritativeness. (Otherwise, links or whatever other metric Google uses to determine which websites to include in the snippet).

So, to get a placement in this feature, inherently, your list should mention things that other websites have mentioned. The presence of the SERP feature means that the user needs to click on your article specifically to see the original ideas. By default, the user sees only unoriginal ideas as part of the SERP’s top result – the snippet. 

This creates a vicious loop of unoriginality, fuelling top results for queries, which are highly important for users and publishers alike. In my opinion, this is one of the reasons why people turn to TikTok, YouTube or forums to get more personal recommendations and original ideas for this type of query.

Why I care about this – and why you should, too

To recap, here are some of the key issues:

  • Google’s From sources across the web is, by definition, a programmatic SEO format, but it’s not a format that uses any original content.
  • The information in Google’s databases, informing the snippet, appears not to be fact-checked or frequently updated and often presents information from a limited number of low-quality sources that do not align with the user’s search intent.
  • These snippets dominate commercial intent queries, often taking the first position when they appear in search results and can only be outranked by sponsored slots.
  • In many ways, the entire process of how the snippet is built and how well it addresses the search intent is against Google’s own content quality guidelines. Yet, the same are applied to demote independent publishers. 
  • Overall, this featured snippet leads to the erasure of original ideas and, in some cases, even disadvantages entire minority groups, all done for the sake of higher ad revenue on Google’s end.

I have a sense of what many readers will say in relation to my analysis, and I want to dispel some myths: 

  • “You’re not a good SEO! If you’re a good SEO you wouldn’t be worried about this and you will just find a way to be featured in the snippet, one way or another.”
    • So, unless we all decide to put on our black hat and ditch any integrity in how we do our work, we’re screwed? 
  • “Google has a duty to shareholders to keep costs down and raise profitability.”
    • As a shareholder, I understand that. I also think they have a duty to people who do billions of searches on their platform daily to surface accurate information based on authoritative sources relevant to the user query and overall move toward better quality search results and improve their product, Google Search.
  • “If they only change which pages they pull the information from, the problem will be solved.”
    • I disagree. Fundamentally, this snippet reduces the visibility of truly original ideas. Its structure and design fail to provide the much-needed context on the included list items, their relevancy to the user’s search and the selection process behind the list items and sources added in the snippet.

I hope that collectively, as an industry, we can advocate for change and compel Google Search product managers to heed our concerns.

This analysis aims to shed light on the challenges faced by users, service providers, and publishers, illustrating why ranking organically for commercial intent queries has become increasingly challenging without resorting to sponsored placements on third-party sites or Google Ads.


Contributing authors are invited to create content for Search Engine Land and are chosen for their expertise and contribution to the search community. Our contributors work under the oversight of the editorial staff and contributions are checked for quality and relevance to our readers. The opinions they express are their own.


Popular Articles